Tuesday, February 26, 2013

3 critiques

Anthony- I really enjoyed his photos, I know you were saying before that his "three emotions" photograph would have been better if it was somewhat cropped more in, to focus just on the "confused" man, but I disagree. I enjoyed all of the things in front of him because it showed clutter and chaos. It made his emotion more believable that he was in a hurry and annoyed or confused about a text message that he received.


Evan- Evan's photos were my favorite. Though he said that the photo of him was a photo that everyone else would have was somewhat unbelievable, I actually understood what he was talking about. You said in that class the photo was a little staged and that it wasnt anything that special. I have to disagree when I saw that picture I couldn't help but relate to it, and Im sure most people in the class have been through a night where they drank a little much and had to spend the night with their toilet. I thought this photo was taken very well.


Melanie- In class you mentioned that her "artsy" photo was a little cliche and that we should never take a picture of some one else's art and try to make it our own. I have to disagree I especially enjoyed her photo of the bananas in the bowl because of the fact that she focused on the painted bowl rather than the fruit. I thought the colors were beautiful and stood out great next to the browning bananas.

1 comment:

  1. Crowded frame would lead to his confused look makes sense still could use the chaos shown maybe more poetically if that makes sense?

    I impinge that is a common experience there was something about the bottle being there and the sitting facing the toilet looked staged but it was far from ordinary, I do agree with you there.

    I think you can certainly make other art your own I think the inclusion of browning bananas in the picture is a step in that direction. But for me most of those colors are the doing of the person making the plate.

    ReplyDelete